It feels like you give several closely related arguments, each individually appearing to be against something, but after reading this I'm still not clear on what you're arguing against or even if there's a unified thing here rather than several different things.

Maybe it would help me if you were to take a step back, cite some sources that you specifically want to understand and/or argue against, and explain your thoughts in a way that looks more like a brief history than a long argument?

"Why is he making so many replies?"

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fBF8GuBmQnNCBzh6Y/multiple-arguments-multiple-comments