Comment by CasparHenderson on David Pearce on Hedonic Moral realism · 2010-02-06T10:04:17.476Z · LW · GW

If an AMA does not embody an extrapolation of 'primitive human moral psychology' how can we be sure that it will attribute value to what someone who does have that primitive psychology judges to be valuable -- in this case a 'cosmic abundance of hypervaluable states'?