Posts

Comments

Comment by FloraFuture on Welcome to Less Wrong! (2012) · 2013-04-08T18:40:03.095Z · LW · GW

People who agree definitely can offer that, but people who disagree are going to be better at it and more motivated. They push you harder to strengthen your own reasoning and articulate it well. If you try to compare the two in practice I think you'll notice a huge difference. I think it can be uncomfortable sometimes to challenge and be challenged, but it doesn't need to be about status or putting other people down. In fact, it can be friendly and supportive. I really recommend it to people who enjoy critical thinking and want to challenge themselves in unexpected ways.

Comment by FloraFuture on Welcome to Less Wrong! (2012) · 2013-04-04T21:05:05.290Z · LW · GW

Sorry, I didn't mean to say that I can't challenge myself at all. In practice I do try to challenge myself. I am saying that debates, where other people challenge me, help me fill in the gaps where I miss things, or am not being objective.

Sometimes my inner dialogue says, "The way I'm thinking about this makes to me, and it seems logical and sound. I have tried but I can't think of anything wrong with it." And then I'll explain my reasoning to someone who disagrees, and they might say for example, "but you haven't considered this fact, or this possibility." And they're right, I haven't. That doesn't necessarily mean I'm wrong, or that they're right, but it does mean that I haven't been 100% effective at challenging myself to justify my own positions.

Comment by FloraFuture on Welcome to Less Wrong! (2012) · 2013-04-03T01:34:03.899Z · LW · GW

Very, very often. Most of it is small steps, like minor adjustments, but a few debates/discussions have completely changed my thinking. I have definitely been wrong about a lot of things in the past. Some of my errors I have noticed through my own critical thinking. But I would say that most of my positions today have been shaped by how much I've let other people challenge them.

Comment by FloraFuture on Welcome to Less Wrong! (2012) · 2013-04-03T01:30:15.153Z · LW · GW

You're right, but I don't think I'm alone in sometimes missing events that I should be taking into account, or not always being objective in the conclusions I make with them.

Comment by FloraFuture on Welcome to Less Wrong! (2012) · 2013-04-03T01:27:19.333Z · LW · GW

lol that makes sense, I forget sometimes about Omegle's reputation

Comment by FloraFuture on Welcome to Less Wrong! (2012) · 2013-04-01T01:28:52.972Z · LW · GW

I totally agree with this. Really well said.

Comment by FloraFuture on Welcome to Less Wrong! (2012) · 2013-04-01T01:27:51.129Z · LW · GW

What do you mean? They were just friendly discussions, nothing super notable. I felt like all of them shared the same basic philosophy as me, so I felt like this was a community that I had a lot in common with.

Comment by FloraFuture on Welcome to Less Wrong! (2012) · 2013-04-01T01:24:41.070Z · LW · GW

My objective is definitely to come to the correct conclusion. I know sometimes my positions win because other people can't argue their positions well, but without those debates, I have no way to really challenge my own ideas. I think as people go I tend to be self-critical, but even I can have blind spots. So I use debates to see if and where I have gone wrong. I've definitely gone wrong many times before.

I don't believe in persuasion as "trickery" -- I see it as more getting past the emotional barriers for a real, productive discussion.

Comment by FloraFuture on Welcome to Less Wrong! (2012) · 2013-03-30T01:45:39.225Z · LW · GW

Hi everyone,

A few of you have met me on Omegle. I finally signed up and made an account here like you guys suggested.

About me: I'm 26 years old, and my hobbies include creative writing and PC games. My favorite TV show is Rupaul's Drag Race.

I think I share almost all of the main positions that people tend to have in this community. But I actually find disagreements more interesting, so that's mainly what I'm here for. One of my passions in life is debating. I did debate team and that sort of thing when I was younger, but now I'm more interested in how to seriously persuade people, not just debating for show. I still have a lot of improving to do, though. If anyone wants to exchange notes or get some tips, then let me know.

Love,

Flora