Posts

Hard vs Soft in fields as attitudes towards model collision 2021-04-20T18:57:51.401Z
Most Analogies Are Wrong 2021-04-16T19:53:41.940Z
My Thoughts on the Apperception Engine 2021-02-25T19:43:55.929Z

Comments

Comment by Jemist on Most Analogies Are Wrong · 2021-04-20T20:09:11.109Z · LW · GW

Good point, perhaps my view is skewed as I do almost all of my learning and explaining in technical fields (mostly chemistry and biology) and with people who are on a similar knowledge level to me. I can imagine that in a situation of trust but little knowledge (e.g. I am explaining my work to a family member) or in a different field to mine they would be more useful.

I think my assessment here may have been too focussed on a specific subset of analogy use, which I did not properly specify in the post.

Edit to clarify: I still believe intuition pumps in philosophy are a bad sort of analogy in that they are too easily manipulated to serve the philosophical interests of the speaker

Comment by Jemist on D&D.Sci II: The Sorceror's Personal Shopper · 2021-01-13T15:56:50.046Z · LW · GW

Red or green weapons i.e. swords, longswords, battleaxes (not axes or hammers though) seem to have a mana scaling dependent on their +n modifier (although green weapons have a drop-off at higher modifiers. It appears to be a clear enough pattern that it's not a statistical artefact. I've not found anything else about the tools or jewellery though.