Comment by Mikko_Rauhala on Zombies! Zombies? · 2008-04-04T11:17:54.000Z · LW · GW

All pretty much in prior agreement here (though no, I haven't stated "the listener caught in the act of listening" quite so eloquently either).

Personally I just go by the priori that zombies are simply not logically possible. Postulating that they are "seems" to lead to quite contrived and/or internally inconsistent scenarios, as you lay out.