Meetup : Boston - Schelling Day

post by Vika · 2014-03-27T17:08:50.148Z · LW · GW · Legacy · 6 comments

Contents

  Discussion article for the meetup : Boston - Schelling Day
  Discussion article for the meetup : Boston - Schelling Day
None
6 comments

Discussion article for the meetup : Boston - Schelling Day

WHEN: 16 April 2014 07:00:00PM (-0400)

WHERE: Citadel House, 98 Elm St Apt 1, Somerville, MA

Schelling Day is a rationalist holiday (designed by Ben Landau-Taylor) that is about sharing important and personal things in our lives, and getting to know each other better. The holiday involves a fun ritual for talking about feelings, and a potluck dinner.

Here is Ben's LW post describing Schelling Day http://lesswrong.com/lw/h2t/schelling_day_a_rationalist_holiday/

There is some debate on the most Schelling time to gather and discuss feelings, but the birthday of Thomas Schelling (April 14) seemed like a good choice. Last year's debut of Schelling Day was a great success, and we look forward to holding it again!

The schedule for Schelling Day is as follows:

7pm - arrival

7:30pm - ceremony begins

8:30pm - dinner and socializing

Discussion article for the meetup : Boston - Schelling Day

6 comments

Comments sorted by top scores.

comment by Ben_LandauTaylor · 2014-03-28T00:29:08.712Z · LW(p) · GW(p)

I'll flag that I'm currently working on revisions to the holiday based on feedback from last time. Expect that to be posted soon.

comment by V_V · 2014-03-27T23:59:55.171Z · LW(p) · GW(p)

This sort of things continue to give me cultish vibes. I don't know exactly what you are doing in these sessions, but the accounts I've read remind me of stuff like the "Synanon Game".

Replies from: fubarobfusco, therufs
↑ comment by fubarobfusco · 2014-03-28T00:31:48.082Z · LW(p) · GW(p)

Can you imagine some piece of evidence you could hear about these events that would make them sound more "cultish"?

Can you imagine some piece of evidence you could hear about them that would make them sound less "cultish"?

What kinds of things might an aversion to "cultishness" protect you from? (Some I can think of: Giving all your money to the Church of Scientology; being sexually abused by a guru you trust; being alienated from your family and friends because they think you're a heretic or into scary weird shit.)

If you could take a moment to read Isaac Bonewits' "ABCDEF", does his effort to categorize some of the bad things about "cults" help at all?

Replies from: V_V
↑ comment by V_V · 2014-03-28T10:58:55.469Z · LW(p) · GW(p)

Can you imagine some piece of evidence you could hear about these events that would make them sound more "cultish"? Can you imagine some piece of evidence you could hear about them that would make them sound less "cultish"?

Yes.

What kinds of things might an aversion to "cultishness" protect you from? (Some I can think of: Giving all your money to the Church of Scientology; being sexually abused by a guru you trust; being alienated from your family and friends because they think you're a heretic or into scary weird shit.)

These seem to be good examples of potential dangers. More include believing stupid nonsense, doing generally irrational things, being locked into an exploitative social network, etc.

Replies from: fubarobfusco
↑ comment by fubarobfusco · 2014-03-31T15:37:46.819Z · LW(p) · GW(p)

These seem to be good examples of potential dangers. More include believing stupid nonsense, doing generally irrational things, being locked into an exploitative social network, etc.

I think I have a better image of your concerns, but it's still fuzzy. Could you go into more detail?

(This is on my mind a lot because I recently got in touch with an old friend who turns out to be deeply creeped out by LW and CFAR in a way I'm trying to understand better.)

Is "stupid nonsense" the same as "false beliefs"?

I'm unsure about "doing irrational things", too. I have acquaintances who consider pursuing intimate relationships to be "doing irrational things", and others who consider the same of playing board games. So I hope you can be more specific.

"Being locked into an exploitative social network" is a huge big scary serious concern. That's why I linked to "ABCDEF" above, since it's intended as a guide to avoid those, written by someone who has experience as a member and leader of a large number of nonconformist social groups (namely, neopagan religious groups). Did you get a chance to read that?

↑ comment by therufs · 2014-04-10T03:14:27.706Z · LW(p) · GW(p)

I don't know exactly what you are doing in these sessions

I don't know exactly; I wasn't there and it's possible Ben_LandauTaylor made everything up and brainwashed everyone into going along. This all said, have you read the writeup?