divine carrot

post by Alok Singh (OldManNick) · 2022-11-10T20:50:09.110Z · LW · GW · 2 comments

Contents

2 comments

(some writing without hesitation or editing. possibly with repetition and deviation.)

The classic reinforcement technique is carrot and stick.

Pure stick tends to breed resentment and laziness. Pure carrot breeds similarly, since you’re not doing anything.

There’s a divine carrot too: doing things because they are sacred to you. They are worthwhile.

Go work in the desert and at night, dance around on drugs and feel sacred things.

Pull your actions into the world. All of the world, including the strange bits of experience that spark curiosity.

Enough of that and the stick can fade. Genuine curiosity can take its place. Even if each moment does not spark that curiosity, a genuine desire to see the end point because you’ve never seen it before can.

Over a long enough timeline, even punishments lose their sting as long as they can be survived.

Rewards lose their luster as one acclimates.

Overdoing the desert strategy isn’t much better, since it pulls the unusual too far into ordinary experience, and diminishes the sense of awe that drives one in the first place.

2 comments

Comments sorted by top scores.

comment by Jarred Filmer (4thWayWastrel) · 2022-11-10T21:55:08.100Z · LW(p) · GW(p)

I love "divine carrot" as a term! I think a lot about what it would mean to totally replace stick as motivation, like societies getting off of "burning coal indoors for warmth" maybe humans can "get off burning suffering for motivation"

comment by JacobW38 (JacobW) · 2022-11-11T08:38:24.966Z · LW(p) · GW(p)

You've described habituation, and yes, it does cut both ways. You also speak of "pulling the unusual into ordinary experience", as though that is undesirable, but contrarily, I find exactly that a central motivation to me. When I come upon things that on first blush inspire awe, my drive is to fully understand them, perhaps even to command them. I don't think I know how to see anything as "bigger than myself" in a way that doesn't ring simply as a challenge to rise above whatever it is.