Posts

Comments

Comment by hotpomm on Sherlockian Abduction Master List · 2024-11-03T11:38:49.964Z · LW · GW

Hi, I read the list and what about callous on hands.

I think that it is quite a popular sign to see among wheightlifters, bodybuilders and generally most people who seriously go to the gym. 

I would give this a high confidence as long as the callouses are at the start of the fingers so on the palm of the hand technically right below the first knuckle. 

Additionally if there are some callouses on the thumb that can indicate that they do olympic weightlifting meaning snatch and clean and jerk because there everybody uses a hook grip where the thumg is squeezed on to the bar by the other fingers to increase grip strength. 

Generally I do think that from the callous you could also get to when they have last been there and with what intensity or weight they train. People on a higher level tend to have callous and rough skin already built up as far as I know, while people who are starting out or haven't trained consistently with exercises that include pulling as those exercises are harder on the hands might have some but since it won't be a mature cornea it is likely to fall of and be unsmooth.

The callouses are different from those that climbers get, as climbing and bouldering has a way bigger emphasis on the fingers so if the callous is also on the fingers on can conclude, that they climb.

If there are no callouses this doesn't have to mean that they do not train as some people use lifting straps, but overall I have been able to observe it quite often with others but also when looking at my hands depending on if I was actively going to the gym or took a couple months break.

There might be other reasons for getting callous on the hands but I could not think of any that produce the same characteristics.

This is my first post so please be kind and let me know what you think