Preppers Are Too Negative on Objects

post by jefftk (jkaufman) · 2024-12-18T02:30:01.854Z · LW · GW · 1 comments

Contents

1 comment

Don't just buy some gear, throw it in a closet, pat yourself on the back, and move on. You are not prepared unless you practice with your supplies and plans. —The Prepared

Preppers are often pretty negative on people who, after realizing disasters are worth taking seriously want to go out and buy a bunch of stuff. And it makes sense: there is a lot of marketing aimed at preppers, pushing all sorts of things that are marginally useful, and it's healthy to have some pushback. On the other hand, it seems to me when thinking through disaster scenarios it's just really useful to have stuff. And if you're only up for putting a short amount of time into this I think it generally makes sense to allocating that time to figuring out what you need, buying that, and then moving on.

Our world is complex and supply chains are long. A disaster doesn't even have to be very big (ex: one broken ship, and a bad law) before people with the most precarious supply start seeing empty shelves. Having bought what you need in advance instead of waiting until you see a disaster coming means you're not competing with everyone else for the stuff that's already in stores, which is (a) selfishly good because you're not risking missing out and (b) altruistically good because you're reducing demand during a shortage.

This is not to say that practice and knowledge are not important, but I think they should be lower priorities for most people than getting the basics together.

Comment via: facebook, mastodon, bluesky

1 comments

Comments sorted by top scores.

comment by nim · 2024-12-18T03:52:22.204Z · LW(p) · GW(p)

Yep. I'd also add a couple other factors that seem to play into the prepper object negativity memeplex:

  • "an object solves this problem" is something of a cognitive stop sign to most people -- tabooing the "object solved it" concept forces more accurate thinking about what one's options would be without the object
  • prepper proclivities seem to have a substantial overlap with hoarding disorders. With any hoarding comorbidity, "i have the object" does not imply "I can find the object and retrieve it in good condition".