Comment by fateswarm on Looking for proof of conditional probability · 2013-03-26T00:16:54.871Z · LW · GW

I find this set of answers being top rated quite disturbing to be honest.

There are several people in the same main thread pointing out that

a) There ways to define it that would make it obviously violating basic intuition and hence a disconnection of it from intuition does have limits

b) There are intuitive solutions to the problem that may reach a proof for it and hence the whole argument to be unfounded.