Posts

Comments

Comment by Ian Roberts (ian-roberts) on Leslie's Firing Squad Can't Save The Fine-Tuning Argument · 2020-09-21T07:49:57.082Z · LW · GW

In this Firing Squad analogy there is another possibility that could be considered.

We have -
1. The firing squad missed by design.
2. The firing squad missed due to poor marks-person-ship.

Add
3. God intervened to deflect the bullets.

Lest anybody scoff at this, remember the attempt to kill pope JP II - by John Paul II's assessment, "It was a mother's hand that guided the bullet's path,"