Comment by John_T._Kennedy on Moral Error and Moral Disagreement · 2008-08-11T07:02:52.000Z · LW · GW

Mike,

"I do not eat steak, because I am uncertain of what my own morality outputs with respect to steak-eating. It seems reasonable to me to imagine that cows are capable of experiencing pain, of fearing death. Of being, and ceasing to be. If you are like the majority of human beings, you do eat steak. The propositions I have suggested do not seem reasonable to you."

Accepting your propositions for the sake of argument, I still find that eating steak seems reasonable.