Posts

The Potential Impossibility of Subjective Death 2024-07-04T18:17:28.141Z

Comments

Comment by VictorLJZ on The Potential Impossibility of Subjective Death · 2024-08-27T13:38:51.477Z · LW · GW

Yea I'm not really trying to make any action-relevant point, just pointing out that if we accept three premises which are not that uncommonly held here on LessWrong we get something weird.  Also if anything this makes me more scared of death since I would have no idea or control of how I am "respawned" and by whom.

And FWIW I'm skeptical of the reduced measure response to quantum immortality, it feels like cope to me. I don't intuitively see why I should not care about my anticipated experiences more than some mathematical construct.

Comment by VictorLJZ on The Potential Impossibility of Subjective Death · 2024-07-06T02:13:54.472Z · LW · GW

Thanks! Will check them out.

Comment by VictorLJZ on The Potential Impossibility of Subjective Death · 2024-07-05T15:44:38.701Z · LW · GW

Yep, I have already included this in my post itself.

Comment by VictorLJZ on The Potential Impossibility of Subjective Death · 2024-07-05T15:43:13.925Z · LW · GW

The point of the third assumption is that those revival simulations are not just similar to you, but actually "you". "You" of this instant is a particular observer-moment that is being computed in a multitude of quantum branches or universes.

Comment by VictorLJZ on The Potential Impossibility of Subjective Death · 2024-07-05T15:42:21.380Z · LW · GW

I believe this point has been made by others, that QI should be considered horrifying rather than an escape from death.

I agree, though this misses the point since I never rendered a value judgment on whether being immortal this way is "good" or "bad". I was simply stating a neutral argument as to why we are probably immortal if we accept the three assumptions I laid out.

Comment by VictorLJZ on The Potential Impossibility of Subjective Death · 2024-07-05T12:31:38.963Z · LW · GW

See the argument for quantum immortality, mine is similar to that but involves revival simulations in other worlds rather than just future branches.

Comment by VictorLJZ on The Potential Impossibility of Subjective Death · 2024-07-05T12:25:51.329Z · LW · GW

Will do, have heard great things about it!

Comment by VictorLJZ on The Potential Impossibility of Subjective Death · 2024-07-05T02:31:26.902Z · LW · GW

The same way one "should expect" to wake up from sleep the next morning. "You" of this instant is a particular observer-moment that is being computed in a multitude of quantum branches or universes. Here the argument is that when you die, there will be quantum branches or other universes computing observer-moments of you being revived, and hence you are guaranteed to be "revived" after death from a subjective point of view.

Could you elaborate on the ground truth part? I'm not sure I understand.