CronoDAS's Shortform

My father thinks that ASI is going to be impractical to achieve with silicon CMOS chips because Moore's law is eventually going to hit fundamental limits - such as the thickness of individual atoms - and the hardware required to create it would end up "requiring a supercomputer the size of the Empire State Building and consume as much electricity as all of New York City".

Needless to say, he has very long timelines for generally superhuman AGI. He doesn't rule out that another computing technology could replace silicon CMOS, he just doesn't think it would be practical unless that happens.

My father is usually a very smart and rational person (he is a retired professor of electrical engineering) and he loves arguing, and I suspect that he is seriously overestimating the computing hardware it would take to match a human brain. Would anyone here be interested in talking to him about it? Let me know and I'll put you in touch.

Update: My father later backpedaled and said he was mostly making educated guesses on limited information, that he knows that he really doesn't know very much about current AI, and isn't interested enough to talk to strangers online - he's in his 70s and if AI does eventually destroy the world it probably won't be in his own lifetime. :/