Mapping of enneagram to MTG personality types

I disagree with some of these.

1 fits white-blue better than white-red.

I'm not entirely sure what 2 fits, but black-green isn't it. White-red, maybe? [EDIT: Much like 4, it's actually 3 colours. White-red-green.]

3 is more black-blue than black-white, although white is a strong third.

4 really works better with 3 colours (blue-green-red).

5 isn't red. It's pretty close to mono-blue, but if I had to give it a second, it'd be blue-green.

6 is weird. Black has the trust issues, but doesn't fit much else. I'd say white-blue-red.

7 is red-blue, not red-green.

8 is black-red, with green if you add a third.

9 is green-white.

Hey Alexei, sorry for writing here, I tried it at https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/Ckg5JS8E5QXYhM89r/credence-calibration-game-faq [LW · GW]

I know it's been a while since this game was developed, but I've discovered it recently and I want to make a better one. More question types, community-contributed and voted questions, categories, profiles; cross-platform web app, themes, better UI etc.

It's of course going to be open-source.

Would you like to help with math model for questions and evaluating, or maybe with development?

galatyuk.ilya AT gmail

Interesting attempt!

I identify strongly as Enneagram Type 1 (feels like I'm the textbook case-- the extreme fit is what persuaded me to take a woo personality system seriously), but also score/feel extremely low on Red. (There's the word-association-identification test somewhere, and that's one place I had minimum red.)

A hypothesis I have is that although I do value freedom/flexibility/autonomy (Red stuff), I never feel at much risk of having those taken away (because of my Black?) and so feel no special need to protect them, no need to rebel, etc.

Simic here: Never heard of enneagram before. I generally model people based on their fear so I like the axises it uses to evaluate people; but honestly every one of them feels like they fit except one and even then I could stretch it to kinda fit. Kinda like the Forer Effect ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnum_effect ). Posting mostly to combat publishing(?) bias where I expect you to only be able to find posts by people who fit the system really well.