0 comments
Comments sorted by top scores.
comment by Viliam · 2022-09-28T19:11:53.451Z · LW(p) · GW(p)
I really enjoyed the first 60% of the story, and then it became... too long. Not sure if this is just about me, or if others have a similar reaction.
But, I get ahead of myself. How did things come to this point?
Not sure if this is just a rationalization, but at this moment you switched from present moment to retrospective, which removed the tension. Until this point, I felt like the story could go in many possible directions. (Who is Bruce Hance? What are his actual plans? Will the protagonist hack this device, and maybe reprogram people to worship him instead?) After this point, I felt like "okay, this is obviously a metaphor for a religion" and stopped expecting anything that wouldn't fit this metaphor. The ending was nice again, though.
Replies from: alexbeyman↑ comment by Alex Beyman (alexbeyman) · 2022-09-28T19:33:23.507Z · LW(p) · GW(p)
It was originally two novellas. I combined them, not seeing a point to publishing them separately. Should I separate them?
Replies from: Viliam, ben-lang↑ comment by Viliam · 2022-09-29T11:35:10.469Z · LW(p) · GW(p)
I think you should not act on my advice alone. I might be an outlier.
Furthermore, even if I correctly detected what makes the story worse (for a group of people larger than myself) it does not automatically mean that following my advice would improve it. People are better at detecting what they don't like than at improving things. (For example, I could say which meals taste better and which worse, but I couldn't cook the meals I like most.)
The last objection is that, in long term, rewriting this story is irrelevant. If my complaint makes sense (which still remains to be verified), the best reaction is to keep writing other things, and not make the same mistake again.
So... I guess just leave it as it is. If you later decide to publish it elsewhere, probably two parts will be better. When writing new stories, consider not changing the style in the middle (or if you do, keep the parts separate).
↑ comment by Ben (ben-lang) · 2022-09-29T12:19:40.125Z · LW(p) · GW(p)
Possibly. I had great fun with the first half of this story, and then I saw where the scroll thingy on my screen was and so stopped with the intention of coming back for the second half. (Which I just did. Second half also great fun!) I don't think its a flaw in the story, I think that it might just be that its length puts it as a bit of an outlier in terms of webpage reading.
Solar flares are a great plot device for "I need some machine to malfunction".
Replies from: alexbeyman↑ comment by Alex Beyman (alexbeyman) · 2022-09-29T21:16:28.225Z · LW(p) · GW(p)
Also to set up the visitors at the end, who I still feel arrived too abruptly
Replies from: Vanilla_cabs, ben-lang↑ comment by Vanilla_cabs · 2022-09-30T09:56:19.806Z · LW(p) · GW(p)
My initial reaction to their arrival was "now this is dumb". It just felt too different from the rest, and too unlikely to be taken seriously. But in hindsight, the suddenness and unlikelihood of their arrival work well with the final twist. It's a nice dark comedic ending, and it puts the story in a larger perspective.
↑ comment by Ben (ben-lang) · 2022-09-29T22:07:01.828Z · LW(p) · GW(p)
It is abrupt, but to me that wasn't a bad thing. If them arriving had taken an extra x paragraphs but the story worked out exactly the same way I think that for me that would be worse not better. If there was some clever way of hinting them earlier maybe. The solar flare works quite well for that.
comment by Alexei · 2022-09-27T21:46:36.736Z · LW(p) · GW(p)
Excellent! Maybe there’s a way to pitch this for a Black Mirror episode.
Replies from: alexbeyman↑ comment by Alex Beyman (alexbeyman) · 2022-09-28T02:08:14.538Z · LW(p) · GW(p)
I would need an agent for that. I am in the process of sending query letters to agents specializing in the genres I write.
comment by Flaglandbase · 2022-09-27T14:43:11.196Z · LW(p) · GW(p)
This is a bit like how Scientology has tried to spread, but the E-hance is much better than the E-meter.